JULY 25, 1864:
As the
dark summer of 1864 continued, Lincoln’s popularity continued to plummet and
the idea that he would occupy the White House after March 4th next
was nearing the inner bounds of outlandishness. Knowing that Lincoln’s defeat
in November would mean the ascent of the Peace Democrats to power and likely
Southern independence, the Confederate government was naturally motivated to
create discord in the North on the scale of the New York City Draft Riots of
the previous summer.
Jefferson Davis’ Cabinet devised a grandiose plan to
infiltrate Confederate agents into northern cities, including Chicago and New
York, and commit widespread acts of arson. Fifteen million dollars was set
aside for this purpose. Confederate agents were instructed to ally themselves
with, and help arm, Copperhead organizations like the Knights of The Golden
Circle (K.G.C.), the Sons of Liberty, the Order of the Lone Star, and the Order
of American Knights (O.A.K.), who would seize control of important buildings in
major Union cities.
The history and membership of these groups is murky at best.
Some sources hold that men as disparate as the actor John Wilkes Booth and
former U.S. President Franklin Pierce belonged to these secret societies. The
purpose of these groups was to overthrow the Lincoln Administration in a
violent coup d’etat and restore
slavery with the help of the South. With slavery restored, reunification would
follow.
The signal for the advent of this staged “revolution” was to
have been the arrest of the exiled Copperhead leader Clement Vallandigham, who
had returned to the United States illegally in June 1864. However, the Lincoln
Administration simply ignored Vallandigham’s return. Also, the pro-Southern
secret societies in the North were far smaller and far more disorganized than the
men in Richmond had imagined. Additionally, unlike the Copperheads (many of
whom had been radicalized), the mainstream Peace Democrats were seeking peace, not additional armed rebellions.
They not only refused to work with the Copperheads and their Southern agents provocateurs, but turned on them.
Many ended up in Union jails. Lastly, most of the radical groups had been
infiltrated by pro-Northern agents either working for the government or for
pro-Union secret societies such as The Brotherhood of The Union.
The most organized of the pro-Southern secret societies was
the Knights of The Golden Circle. Founded in Ohio on July 4, 1854 as a group
dedicated to the expansion of slavery into Latin America, K.G.C.s called
“filibusters” led insurrectos in
revolt in Nicaragua and in the Caribbean. Ultimately, the U.S. Federal
Government disavowed the filibusters, most of whom were hanged. Regardless, the
Knights of The Golden Circle endured, and after his return from exile, the
Ohio-born Vallandigham was named Supreme Commander of the K.G.C. even though he
publicly made a show of refusing the honor. After the war ended, the K.G.C.
became a White Supremacist group that still exists today.
Regardless of the chaotic character of these secret
societies, individual members (some thoroughly dedicated to their cause, others
mentally unstable, and some both) did manage to organize and carry out smaller
scale acts of terror, aided and abetted by the benign neglect of pro-Confederates
in high places.
The original plot for New York City, as unlikely as it
seems, was to occupy federal buildings, obtain weapons from arsenals, and arm a
crowd of supporters. The insurgents would then raise a Confederate flag over
City Hall and declare that New York City had left the Union and had aligned
itself with the Confederate government in Richmond. This plan was said to be
developed enough that Union agents heard about it and informed the pro-Southern
Governor of New York State, Horatio Seymour, who refused to take any action.